10 Best Pellet Stoves in 2018 – Review and Buying Guide

It can be quite a challenge finding the best pellet stove that will get you through the winter. Keeping in mind the negative effects of the cold, finding a one that fits your needs is super important. After hours of research for the pellet stoves of all kinds, we settled on the stove below.

Top 5 Pellet Stoves Review 2018:

Castle 12327 Serenity
Our Rating: (4.7 / 5)
Brand: Castle Pellet Stove
Heating Area: 1500 Sq. Ft.
Dimensions: 23.8 x 18.5 x 34''
US Stove 4840 Wall Mount
Our Rating: (4.8 / 5)
Brand: US Stove Company
Heating Area: 1,000 Sq. Ft.
Dimensions: 12.4 x 27 x 36''
Pleasant Hearth PH50CABPS
Our Rating: (4.7 / 5)
Brand: Pleasant Hearth
Heating Area: 2200 Sq. Ft.
Dimensions: 31 x 30 x 43.8''
Pleasant Hearth 1,200 Sq. Ft.
Our Rating: (4.6 / 5)
Brand: Pleasant Hearth
Heating Area: 1200 Sq.Ft.
Dimensions: 24.5 x 24.5 x 37.5''
Comfortbilt Pellet Stove HP22
Our Rating: (4.7 / 5)
Brand: Comfortbilt
Heating Area: 2800 Sq. Ft.
Dimensions: 24 x 35 x 30''

Best pick: US Stove 4840

This one comes with a design that is easy to clean not to mention a vent kit and an automatic diagnostic and ignition control that makes it a solid choice no matter your needs.

#1. Castle 12327 Serenity – Best Rated Pellet Stove

Castle 12327 Serenity

  • Performance: 4.6/5
  • Design: 4.9/5
  • Functionality: 4.8/5

It’s time to reinvent the way you heat your home. What better way to do that than to get Castle 12327 Serenity Wood that comes with a smart controller? Besides, Castle Stoves are easy to clean for a hustle free experience.

Design:

Designed with a capacity to heat up your home automatically, this one comes with a weekly time-based heating option if you set up the smart mode. You can also go manual with up to five burn levels that present an alternative to the calendar based heating option. With over 60 percent thermal efficiency you get a stove with a heating capacity capable of covering a 1500 Sq Ft room.

Performance:

If you are looking for convenience, Castle 12327 makes a solid pick. It comes with an LED display that allows you to easily check and monitor its functionality plus with an EPA certification, this one is environmentally safe.

Pros:

  • Sufficient heating of large rooms
  • Features a smart controller for convenience
  • Easy to clean
  • Optional manual option
  • Easy to install

Cons:

  • The thermostat is not quite accurate

#2. US Stove 4840 – Best Pellet Stove For Small Spaces

US Stove 4840

  • Performance: 4.5/5
  • Design: 4.7/5
  • Functionality: 4.6/5

Sometimes all you need is one that will be efficient enough for a small space. Well, if that’s the case, the US Stove 4840 Wall Mount direct Vent Pellet Heater will serve you well. It comes with a 24000 BTU that can keep a 1200 sq ft room warm and cozy.

Design:

In terms of design, this one comes with a vent kit included not to mention an easy to clean construct that is perfect for small spaces. Plus, you also get up to 5 settings of automatic ignition. Furthermore, there is a battery option as well although you will have to purchase it separately.

Performance:

When you have a small room that you need to keep warm, this makes a solid choice. It boasts of a unique compact design that is efficient for heating a 10000 square feet room. However, you will need some help installing this pellets stove.

Pros:

  • Easy maintenance
  • Vent kit available in the package
  • Features an automatic ignition and control

Cons:

  • Installation might require more than one person

#3. Pleasant Hearth PH50CABPS: Best For Money

Pleasant Hearth PH50CABPS

  • Performance: 4.6/5
  • Design: 4.3/5
  • Functionality: 4.7/5

One of the most respected leading brands in the pellet stove manufacturing space is Pleasant Hearth. With years of experience under its belt, there is no doubt that Pleasant Hearth PH50CABPS Cabinet Style is one of their most popular products for its quality.

Design:

It comes with a design that fits the indoor home lifestyle thanks to an inside-outside air kit. In fact, you can use it as a beautiful focal piece of furniture for your home thanks to its eye-catching form and function. Its heating capacity can cover up 2,200 square feet at 85 percent efficiency.

Performance:

This one lets you sit back and enjoy the warmth. You can use the exclusive control unit to set up a preferred temperature and it will self-regulate if you are away.

Pros:

  • Heats up a 2200 square feet room
  • EPA certified
  • Assembly is easy
  • A pleasant ceramic viewing area

Cons:

  • Requires a lot of maintenance

#4. Pleasant Hearth 1,200 Sq. ft– Best For Heating Water or Tea

Pleasant Hearth 1,200 Sq. ft

  • Performance: 4.5/5
  • Design: 4.4/5
  • Functionality: 4.8/5

Perhaps you need one that allows you to do more than just heating up the room. If that’s the case, you can go with Pleasant Hearth 1,200 Square Feet Wood Burning Stove. Apart from heating up your home, it also lets you heat up your water and tea.

Design:

Measuring 11 1/2″ H x 20 3/4″ W x 16 1/4″ D with a door that opens 17″ W x 10″H, this one is small enough to fit nicely into homes with a small living room. It can heat up a 1200sq Ft room and, depending on the firewood you are using, it will manage to keep burning for about 4 to 6 hours.

Performance:

The only downside with this pleasant hearth is the fact that you have to buy your own air intake kit that is sold separately. Its 50,000 btu capacity is, however, a plus not to mention an 81 percent heating efficiency rating.

Pros:

  • 81 percent energy efficient
  • EPA approved for home use
  • Heating capacity of 50,000 BTU

Cons:

  • Only useful with small amounts of firewood
  • Air intake kit is not included

#5. Comfortbilt HP22 – Most Quiet Pellet Stove

Comfortbilt HP22

  • Performance: 4.5/5
  • Design: 4.3/5
  • Functionality: 4.3/5

Comfortbilt is one of the reputable manufacturing company. Comfortbilt HP22 is by far one of their most popular products and for a good reason. It comes with a 1-year warranty and includes kits that bring about convenience for most homeowners.

Design:

With a bay design that presents a large viewing and a powerful blower that delivers 86 percent heating efficiency, this Comfortbilt HP22 comes with an EPA certification for safety and convenience. It also boasts of a programmable thermostat for easy control and a removable ash and pan to make clean up and maintenance bearable.

Performance:

Thanks to a 50,000 BTU heating capacity this stove is a good pick for those who need an efficient corn wood fueled one. It comes with a variable speed blower as well, giving you the convenience you need to keep your home warm.

Pros:

  • Quiet
  • Sides of the stove don’t get hot
  • Comes with a remote control

Cons:

  • Vent kit sold separately

#6. Vogelzang VG5790 Hopper

Vogelzang VG5790 Hopper

  • Performance: 4.3/5
  • Design: 4.4/5
  • Functionality: 4.0/5

Another manufacturer that has a long-standing reputation for helping homeowners reinvent how they heat up their homes is Vogelzang. With the Vogelzang VG5790 Hopper

you get efficiency in a fully automatic one that is easy to use.

Design:

It comes in a durable design that boasts of a large hopper to make work easy in terms of operations not to mention less fuelling requirements.  With an Air wash glass and an LED display on the thermostat, this one offers a nice ceramic viewing that makes it a perfect fit for any home.

Performance:

Even with the durable steel build quality of Vogelzang VG5790 Hopper, there are still some downsides you have to look out for. For instance, its fan can get pretty loud and the unit doesn’t come with an ashtray. If that is not a deal breaker for you, Vogelzang VG5790 Hopper can still be a good deal thanks to its pocket-friendly price tag.

Pros:

  • EPA approved
  • Durable steel construct
  • Pellet capacity of 120 lb
  • Can heat up a 2800 square feet space

Cons:

  • fan gets loud
  • installation is not easy in most cases

#7. Pelpro Pellet Stove PP130

Pelpro Pellet Stove PP130

  • Performance: 4.5/5
  • Design: 4.8/5
  • Functionality: 4.4/5

Pelpro is known for serving residential appliances to many home users. They are leading developers and the Pelpro PP130 is one of their premium built pellet stoves with a dial control and a decent blower.

Design:

Built with a design that is energy conscious, this one brings about convenience with its extended burn time that goes as long as 80 hours. It features 3 heating settings that keep your house warm and cozy. It also comes with a fresh air kit that brings in the oxygen. However, you will have to spend extra on a chimney.

Performance:

This Pelpro PP130 works great all thanks to a design that promoted up to 85 percent heating efficiency. The fan on this stove is quiet and the heater can keep a 2200sq Feet room warm. You also get the convenience of an automatic stove that makes operations a breeze

Pros:

  • Reliable design
  • Features an automatic ignition
  • Easy heat adjustability
  • Efficient heating at 85 percent

Cons:

  • The stove tends to produce smoke in some cases.

#8. US Stove 5500M King Pellet Burner

US Stove 5500M King Pellet Burner

  • Performance: 4.6/5
  • Design: 4.5/5
  • Functionality: 4.4/5

Built by a privately owned conglomerate that boasts of decades of experience in the game, US Stove 5500M King Pellet Burner brings about digital control in a classic looking.

Design:

With the US Stove 5500M King Pellet Burner, you not only get a 25 x 34 x 26 inches but you also get a  fully automated pellet stove that features easy to use electronic controls and autoignition. In case of a negative draft, this one comes with a negative blower that acts as an exhaust that eliminated smoke spillage.

Performance:

In terms of performance, this one from US stove is a good option for those who are environmentally conscious. It burns a carbon-neutral fuel that is clean and easy to store and handle. You can use a scoop to keep the ash out for easy maintaining and thanks to a durable design this one can last for years.

Pros:

  • Easy settings and operations with an LED display
  • Fits multiple heating needs with five heat settings
  • Simple and fast adjustments with digital control

Cons:

  • Does not come with installation material

#9. Comfortbilt Pellet Stove HP 61

Comfortbilt Pellet Stove HP 61

  • Performance: 4.8/5
  • Design: 4.7/5
  • Functionality: 4.4/5

 Apart from the need for a pellet stove that keeps your home warm and cozy, you might just be in need of one that gives your room a decent aesthetics with something to stare at. Well if that is it, this Comfortbilt HP 61 will do it.

Design:

It comes in a carbon black design with a large viewing window that is pleasing to look at. The thermostat is programmable meaning you get a decent amount of control on this 50lb hopper. Furthermore, there is a 1-year warranty available on the parts making it a convenient and durable purchase.

Performance:

In terms of performance, this one goes beyond what you would expect at its price range. It has the capacity to heat up a 2,000sq ft room thanks to its ability to product 50,000 btu with 86 percent burning efficiency. The only downside is that you will need an extra pair of hands to install it.

Pros:

  • Can exceed its heating capacity to keep a 2000 to 3000 sq ft room warm
  • Up to 86 percent burning efficiency
  • It presents a large viewing
  • Programmable thermostat

Cons:

  • Requires help to install

#10. US Stove 5660 Bay

US Stove 5660 Bay

  • Performance: 4.7/5
  • Design: 4.5/5
  • Functionality: 4.6/5

US Stove 5660 Bay is another one from US Stove that gives you even heat distribution wrapped up in a quality built, that you can use for years.

Design:

This ONE comes with an LED display for easy operation not to mention a 120 CF blower that spreads heat evenly. You also get a large bay window design that is great for viewing.

Performance:

This US stove 5660 performs well no matter your heating needs thanks to 6 heat settings that give you options to choose from. And, with its digital controls, you only need to make one-touch adjustments to get what you need.

Pros:

  • Quiet
  • Holds up to 55lb of pellets that lasts for 60 hours
  • Doesn’t include a fresh air kit

Cons

  • Produces a bit of smoke at the beginning of the pellets burning

Buyers Guide: How to pick the best

When it comes to picking a pellet stove that suits your heating needs, there are just too many variations. However, you don’t have to worry. This buyer’s guide will take you through some of the considerations to look out for with a few tips on how to maintain your product.

  • Operation and maintenance

When you get your pallet stove delivered, the first daunting task is how to operate it. The best one come with an automatic ignition or even a digital display that makes control easy and manageable even for beginners. Some will come with an ash pan that helps in the collection of burnt pallets.  In some cases, you will need to have a large pan that makes retrieval of ash easy and maintenance a breeze.

  • Size

Well, there can only be so much size in your house. Depending on your needs you can either go with a small size pellet or a big one. A bigger stove will provide more heating than a small one, however, there are some small sized ones that are built for efficiency and are capable of exceeding their regular heating capacity. The best heat range to target would be a 50000BTU stove.

  • Feeder design

There are two types in this category. There is the top feed and bottom feed pellet stove. With a top feed, you get to reduce chances of the fire burning back into the hopper. On the other hand, the bottom feed is effective in the long run even when you are not using premium quality pellets.

  • Type of Fuel

Their fuel varies from multi-pellet to corn pellets or wood pellets. If you live in an area where there is an abundance of one type of pellet from the other, it is a solid choice to go with a pellet that uses the fuel you can easily get your hands on.

Tip for Better Care

Buying a pellet stove is usually a onetime purchase and most of the time you will want to get a stove that lasts for a long time. Here are some tips that can help.

  • Get your stove checked by a professional annually
  • Use premium quality pellets
  • Regularly clear the ash
  • Clean the exterior as well

Conclusion:

Well, there you have it. Now you can go ahead and make an informed decision on the best pellet stove there is. With our list, you will be able to find both affordable and durable products that cater to your heating needs. Be sure to also look at the buyer’s guide to know what features to look out for.

Author: Steve

Leave a Comment